Airbnb Proposal Stands On False Premise; Let Gig City Be An Open City

Wednesday, May 17, 2017

A City Council proposal to regulate home sharing networks offers false choices and pretends that city government has authority to regulate what private people do in their own houses.

The council will vote June 13 on a proposal by council member Chip Henderson to set up a special district in which residents may, without rezoning, use their houses commercially through sharing networks such as Airbnb.



The phony claim of authority arises from the use of a piece of paper. That piece of paper is a map of the city showing all its districts and neighborhoods.

The map is a form of propaganda. Mapmakers often serve the interests of controlling parties in capitals of ambitious nation-states who survey neighbors and stir concern about external threat and enemies. The map being used by council members is from the regional planning agency, implying that every area of the city, and all its human activity occurring within private dwellings, is subject to the printer of that map and those who gaze upon its traces with an eye to using municipal authority.

In the false choice presented, council members may elect to have parts or all of their respective areas within the district, or outside of the special district. Council members, in other words, decide whether residents in their districts may use Airbnb subject to regulation, or participate in Airbnb only through rezoning.

The City Council should respect private property rights and keep its hands off the private rental market, which in 2016 is estimated to have created $2.5 million in cash flow for private homeowners.

Zoning and external controls upon private property are unconstitutional, and are ripe for legal challenge to overturn the entire system. Chattanoogans and Hamilton Countians have tolerated zoning for decades without legal challenge.

Councilman Henderson says 500 rental houses in the city exist, but only 25 of them sit in the R-4 zones that theoretically allow them. A petition for rezoning a single lot in a residential area creates opposition, because neighbors fear that the house could be torn down and converted into a store, gas station, condo or office building.

Zoning controls are an offense against innocent and harmless use of private property and private dwellings. Because the city has gone so far as to create a zoning regime, its legislators on the council feel obliged to do something about Airbnb, a Web network that seems to void existing legal categories.

But the city should remain a free market haven, and should make a bold and noisy showing that it has a hands-off perspective on Airbnb and the sharing economy.

For the city to try to control the sharing economy, it declares is proprietary interest in the private property and private doings of private men and women in their own personal residences. It should slap cold water on its face, brace itself, and keep its hands out of the people’s business.

The Gig City with its Internet boulevards and its national reputation should act consistently with its pretensions of being an advanced and forward-looking city.

It should leave alone Airbnb investors, families and homeowners — and their many out-of-town guests — and declare itself an open city.

David Tulis

davidtuliseditor@gmail.com

— David Tulis hosts a talk show 9-11 a.m. weekday mornings at Noogaradio 1240 AM 92.7 FM, covering local economy and free markets in Chattanooga and beyond.



City Council’s Critical Call—Creek Consensus?

The Friars Branch Stream Restoration Project cost the city $1.2 million after new homes were flooded along Hickory Valley Road caused by inadequate stormwater management during the development of Hamilton Place upstream.  The residents dealing with the floodwaters suffered cleanup costs as did the city.  Allowing homebuilders to cover up more surface with impervious homes ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The School Board Bullies

When the good people of Signal Mountain join with their loved ones to give thanks for many, many blessings on this hallowed Thursday, you can bet the Hamilton County Department of Education will be on nary a list. For the past year a diligent advisory committee has studied the feasibility of forming its own school district and exactly one week prior to Thanksgiving, the misguided ... (click for more)

Spring Creek Elementary Closed Monday And Tuesday Due To Fire In Boiler Room

There was a fire early Monday around  4 a.m.  in the boiler room at Spring Creek Elementary School causing the school to be closed Monday and Tuesday.    Damage from the fire was contained to the boiler room but the utilities to the building are also in the damaged boiler area which left the school without power, heat and other necessities to have ... (click for more)

Tony Williams, 26, Shot On Dodson Avenue Late Sunday Night

Tony Williams, 26, was shot late Sunday night on Dodson Avenue. Chattanooga Police responded at 11:50 p.m.,  to the 900 block of Dodson Avenue on a shooting.   Upon arrival, police located the victim who was suffering from a non-life threatening gunshot wound. HCEMS responded and transported the victim to a nearby hospital. The victim advised police that the ... (click for more)

LSU Hammers Vols 30-10 In Hoke's Debut As Interim Coach

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. – Butch Jones is long gone. But Tennessee’s on-field results Saturday were about the same as they’ve been since Georgia humiliated the Vols 41-0 on Sept. 30. Nationally ranked LSU’s defense effectively stymied Tennessee’s offense most of the game and the Tigers got two rushing touchdowns in a 30-10 SEC victory before an announced crowd of 96,888 at Neyland ... (click for more)

UTC Finishes Tough Season With 10-3 Win Over ETSU

A youthful Tom Arth knew he was facing the biggest coaching challenge of his life back in the spring when he was hired as the next head man for the Chattanooga Mocs football team, but he didn’t know exactly how challenging it would be. It hasn’t been the season that Arth had planned as things didn’t always go as he had hoped, but the best news is that the season finished on a ... (click for more)