Reappraisal Equals Redistribution Of Wealth

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

Here’s a simple and accurate explanation of the Hamilton County property reappraisal results. 

Picture three adjacent property owners–you and your two next door neighbors. One neighbor to your left, one to your right, and you in the middle. Imagine that the county assessor gives one of your neighbors a tax break. That’s easy enough, just by juggling the new appraisals. 

Now, the reappraisal is required by state law, and it must be ‘revenue neutral’–the total amount of property tax collected after reappraisal must be the same as it was before. (Yes, it could be manipulated to produce less tax revenue than before, but we know that’s not gonna happen.) 

So, in the very personal case of you and your two neighbors, if one of them gets a tax cut then you and the other neighbor have to make up the difference. Either you, or the other neighbor, or both of you have to pay more taxes now because one neighbor will be paying less than before. 

On a larger scale, for the entire county, half of the taxpayers got a break this year. And the other half must pay for that break. You and your neighbors may all pay less this year, at someone else’s expense. Or all three of you may have to pay for the windfalls that others got. But whenever one property owner benefits, others will get a larger tax bill to cover it. 

Think about it. The people who work for the county assessor have absolute, unilateral, arbitrary and irresistible legal power to take money from one property owner and give it to another. It is the government version of robbing Peter to pay Paul. The county never loses, and Paul never complains. 

In real terms, the latest reappraisal took money away from half of Hamilton County property owners and gave that same money to the other half of them. Even if your taxes only went up $10, that $10 was taken from you by law and given to someone else as a gift. If that isn’t a redistribution of wealth, what is it? Even if it’s legal, it’s still wrong. 

Here’s an example straight from county records online: One fortunate property owner received a new appraisal of $469,500 – only $1,600 more than last year – while many others got appraisal increases of tens of thousands of dollars. The immediate effect for that one taxpayer is a $300 reduction in his county property tax this year. But the rest of us have to make up for the $300 he’s saving, and for thousands of other similar cases as well. 

Oh – guess which lucky property owner is directly associated with the Assessor’s office?  

Think about it. Half of us should be legitimately (although helplessly) angry, while the other half just smile all the way to the bank with our money. 

It’s not right. 

Larry Cloud
Chattanooga



My Experience With The Assessor’s Board Of Equalization

According to the Hamilton County Website, the County Board of Equalization “hears appeals from citizens who do not agree with their property assessments.” That sounds good. I sure don’t agree with mine. It “exists to give every property owner a chance to be heard. The goal is not to be an appraiser, but to decide values based on consistency, equity, and evidence. When properties ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Writing From Bragg Avenue

Far and away, my favorite comment on destroying statues appeared on my Facebook page the other day and, believe it or not, it was the clear-minded Times Free Press Sports Editor Stephen Hargis who penned, “This statue offends me! It must be torn down!” Underneath his fiery words, the long-suffered UT football fan posted a picture of the bronze monument outside of Bryant-Denny stadium ... (click for more)

Girlfriend Says Wright Was Driving Her PT Cruiser When He Left With Pair Whose Bodies Were Found At Cemetery

The girlfriend of William Howard Wright testified Tuesday that Wright and "Little Tony" were with two youths whose bodies were afterward found in a cemetery at Shepherd. General Sessions Court Judge Clarence Shattuck bound two counts of criminal homicide and especially aggravated robbery to the Grand Jury against Wright. A 17-year-old is facing similar charges. The girlfriend ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Police Pay Increases Announced

Chattanooga Police officers will be earning more under a $1.4 million pay improvement plan announced Tuesday. New officers would get increases in each of their first six years with the department, which has been dealing with a number of newly trained officers going to other cities. City officers now make $35,913 upon joining the force. Under the plan, they will receive about ... (click for more)

Notre Dame Gets Revenge With Boyd-Buchanan

The Notre Dame volleyball team may have felt they let one get away in the championship match of the Hixson Invitational Saturday afternoon against the Boyd-Buchanan Lady Buccaneers, but they were bound to not let it happen again. At least, not during a home match against these same Lady Bucs Tuesday evening in the rowdy confines of their Jack Steiner Sr. Gymnasium. The Lady ... (click for more)

Despite Sloppy Finish, Lady Raiders Sweep McMinn

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – Cleveland High School’s volleyball team came close to completely satisfying its coach Tuesday. The Lady Raiders then got lazy. Coach Trish Flowers, who has another state tournament contender on her hands this season, let the squad feel her displeasure in the postgame huddle. “I was within just a few minutes of being in a good mood,” said Flowers, ... (click for more)