Phil's Lieberman Moment - And Response

Saturday, October 6, 2018

On Friday, Democratic Senate candidate Phil Bredesen came out in support of the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh, the same day Susan Collins announced presumably the key deciding vote. The backlash from the DNC and their special interest groups was swift. Numerous political action committees, including MoveOn.org, announced that they would be withdrawing support for Bredesen in a key battleground state in which Democrats were hoping to pick up another Senate seat.

The main (and largely only) argument presented against the election of Bredesen has largely been that he will be a “puppet” of Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. I'll be the first to raise my hand and say that I don't agree with probably 90%+ of Schumer's positions and philosophies. What I can say is that if you thought Bredesen would do nothing but be a puppet for Schumer, October 5 clearly proved otherwise. We can argue and disagree all day about how we, as a country, got where we are/were with the nomination of Kavanaugh. But the truth is that we’re now past all of those arguments. His nomination at the time I write this is all but confirmed. There will be other opportunities to nominate and seat SCOTUS justices in the future. The main thing we can all agree on from these past three months is that we can do better and we must do better in the future: in the quality in selecting the nominee and in the confirmation and vetting process.

Phil has an opportunity now to tell the DNC the same thing Joe Lieberman told them on Aug. 8, 2006: “Thanks, but no thanks.” Granted, he had just lost the Democratic primary for Senate in Connecticut, but the basic calculus is still the same. Lieberman went on to win the election as an Independent candidate, not because it was the politically right thing to do, but because it was the best thing for Connecticut. His post-2006 voting record shows that he was willing to cross the aisle if it was the best thing for Connecticut and the best thing for the country.

Tennessee now has the same moment to do the same thing for Phil, and Phil likewise now has the same opportunity Lieberman had in 2006. Bredesen is and always has been a champion for Tennessee. The state saw record-breaking economic growth while he was governor and the argument can be made that he laid the current groundwork for the boom in manufacturing that we’re benefiting from today. He has often bucked party lines to accomplish not what was best for him politically, but what was best for Tennessee.

I have always felt strongly that an independent conscience, free from party lines, is a wonderful thing to have in any political candidate, especially at the federal level. No one should ever be so entrenched in their party lines, philosophy, or money that they can’t or won’t work with the other side to get the important things done for this country that need to be done.

Deep partisan brinkmanship led us to the Kavanaugh debacle. The failure of all of us to leave our own echo chambers and do what is necessary (and not always popular) for the greater good of our country over our personal selves is an embarrassment for all of us that we will one day have to explain to our kids and grandkids. Having an independent Bredesen will force the Senate to listen to Tennessee and force all of us to talk to and work with each other (even the ones on the other side who don't agree with us).

I’m a conservative-leaning independent Millennial that was planning on voting for Phil before Oct.5. I’m still planning on voting for him. I sincerely hope you all can swallow your own pride and partisanship and join me.

N
ick Rutledge
Hixson 

* * * 

Yes, he did support Kavanaugh.  Because he has to if he wants to win. And if he does win, it will be the last time chameleon Phil sides with a conservative. 

Tickles me when someone actually falls for this tactic.

Donna Brocato 


Elect Leaders To Preserve Signal Mountain's Small Town Character

Dear Signal Mountain Residents,  Do you care deeply about preserving Signal Mountain's natural beauty and small town character? We do. Over the past year, the town has faced requests to rezone residential properties for commercial use.   These requests might have been approved by the majority of our council, if not for the multitude of residents speaking out against ... (click for more)

East Brainerd For Joda Thongnopnua

Joda Thongnopnua has my vote for District 30 State House of Representatives. I have supported both Republicans and Democrats in the past and I’m very happy that someone of Joda’s caliber is running for this open seat. I have worked alongside Joda professionally and I’ve seen firsthand his work ethic and his great ability to work with others to come up with the best solution.  ... (click for more)

City "Moves Away" From $4 Million Light Show On Walnut Street Bridge

The city is no longer pursuing a plan for a $4,050,000 light show on the Walnut Street Bridge. Dennis Malone, assistant city engineer, told City Council members on Tuesday, "We have moved away from that project." The council had earlier pulled capital funding that had been proposed for the "Ripples of Light" on the historic "walking bridge" that dates to 1891. “Ripples ... (click for more)

Developer Of Publix Grocery At St. Elmo To Go Before Variance Board

The developer of a planned Publix grocery in St. Elmo will go before the City Board of Zoning Appeals on Nov. 7 seeking three variances. Mike Price of MAP Engineers said the grocery has been working with community members to try to come up with an acceptable plan for the site where the former Mt. Vernon Restaurant and Pizza Hut are located. There has been controversy over ... (click for more)

Baylor Wins First Match In State Volleyball

MURFREESBORO – The first match of the 2018 TSSAA State Volleyball Tournament is in the books for the Baylor Lady Red Raiders. The defending Division II, Class AA state champs defeated Father Ryan for the third time this season, Tueday’s match by a 3-1 final at Blackman High School. Wednesday's second match at Siegel High School will be against the Briarcrest Saints, who improved ... (click for more)

East Hamilton Roars Back To Beat Camden, 3-1, In Class 2A State Vollleyball Tourney

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Sleepwalking through a lethargic first set after driving from Chattanooga, East Hamilton awoke and stormed past Camden, 3-1, Tuesday in the first round of the Class 2A state volleyball tournament at Middle Tennessee State University. Scores were 25-9, 22-25, 16-25 and 20-25. The Lady Canes (29-2), who have won 22 straight matches, advanced to the semifinals ... (click for more)