Signal Planning Issues

Sunday, May 27, 2018
In her article entitled: "1st Vote On Controversial Signal Mountain Grocery Proposal Set June 13…,” Gail Perry wrote:

"A town ordinance requires that a decision is made in response to a zoning request within 90 days of the time that the council receives a recommendation, either for or against, from the planning commission.
In that time period, there must be a public hearing which has to be advertised 15 days in advance, and a first and second vote. The council received the recommendation to deny the rezoning request on May 14, making Aug. 14 the deadline.”

It is safe to assume that Ms. Perry accurately reported the discussion at the Town Council May 25 agenda meeting; however, the interpretation given at that meeting of the ordinances on rezoning is simply wrong. The Signal Mountain Town Council is being misled into what could turn out to be a major and majorly expensive mistake - voting on The Keith Corporation’s proposal to decide unilaterally what the Town of Signal Mountain should look like should their 38,000 square foot big box Food City development take hold.

There are many substantive reasons why this rezoning request should fail on its merits, but the procedure used to date has already decided the issue for the Council - it is out of time and may not be approved.

The quoted language from Ms. Perry’s article misinterprets the governing ordinances. There is no ordinance requiring any decision to be made in any time frame, let alone the one being used to mash this square peg into the round hole of the law. The 90 day period comes from Zoning Ordinance 1802.04, but all it requires is that a public hearing be set within 3 months of the Town Council receiving the Planning Commission’s “recommendation.” In the parlance of these ordinances, however, the Planning Commission has never “recommended” anything about this rezoning request. What the Planning Commission did at its April 5 meeting is “disapprove” the rezoning request. Under Ordinance 1802.02, then, it was incumbent on the applicant to request and secure a “favorable vote of a majority of the entire membership” of the Town Council to approve the rezoning within 30 days of submitting the request to the Planning Commission. The applicant failed to do so, rendering the request moot and out of time.

I know. I sat on the Planning Commission for over 8 years and participated in that April 5 vote. Also, I’m a lawyer and able to read the plain language of the governing ordinances for what it is - a declaration by the Town of Signal Mountain that the Land Use Plan is to be honored, that rezoning against the grain of the Land Use Plan is disfavored and that failure to follow the ordinances precludes further action on the request by the Town Council.

Van Bunch 

 



You Reap What You Sow

“Trade wars are good, and easy to win.” - Donald J. Trump (March 2, 2018) The United States has imposed tariffs on its economic allies. Canada, Mexico, and the European Union all became subject to trade penalties of 25 percent on steel, and 10 percent on aluminum starting June 1. This was done at the behest of President Trump. Our allies have retaliated. The EU has begun ... (click for more)

Will God Still Bless America?

Our homeland is in peril Dire straits no doubt Contempt for each other Voiced in scornful shout  We must desire to reconcile Our differences posthaste Beg the Lord for one last chance To earn his saving grace  We need to bind our wounds and heal Before the end is neigh How many tears must we spill Before our soul runs dry?  Heavenly Father, ... (click for more)

Funeral Service For John P. Franklin Will Be Friday; Public Memorial Service Is Thursday Night

Funeral services will be Friday for John P. Franklin, Chattanooga's first elected black official in the post Jim Crow era. Mr. Franklin died Thursday at the age of 96. He will lie in state in the chapel of John P. Franklin Funeral Home from noon until 8:30 p.m. on Wednesday,. Public viewing will resume at 11 a.m. on Thursday at Olivet Baptist Church, and a ... (click for more)

Woman, 20, Killed While Trying To Cross Highway 153 Early Sunday Morning

A woman, 20, was killed early Sunday morning while trying to cross Highway 153. The victim was identified as Ansleigh Kaylyn Harrison. At approximately 1:28 a.m. , Chattanooga Police officers responded to a pedestrian struck at 5256 Highway 153. A Toyota Sequoia driven by 31-year-old Asher Powers was traveling north on Highway 153 in the inside lane. The pedestrian ... (click for more)

Chris Douglas Wins Waterfront Triathlon Sunday

More than a thousand trim and fit men and women gathered at Ross’s Landing Sunday morning for the annual Waterfront Triathlon with McKenzie’s Kirsten Sass the only one of four defending champs to successfully defend her title. There were two races held on Sunday, including a sprint event that included a 400-meter swim, a 12-mile bike ride and a 5K run.   The longer intermediate ... (click for more)

UT Athletics Department To Host Tribute To John Ward On Wednesday

  The University of Tennessee Athletics Department and The Vol Network are hosting a Tribute to "The Voice" event honoring John Ward on Wednesday, June 27, starting at 6 p.m. ET at Thompson-Boling Arena. The legendary broadcasting and marketing icon passed away this week following a lengthy illness. He was 88. Wednesday's event will take on a celebratory ... (click for more)