Randy Smith: Decade of Dysfunction: A Very Accurate Account

Wednesday, July 11, 2018 - by Randy Smith
Randy Smith
Randy Smith
I very seldom do book reviews. In fact, I can't really remember ever doing one at all to be totally honest. I'm bucking that trend today because I just finished Mark Nagi's book," Decade of Dysfunction." The book chronicles the ten year period of struggles of the University of Tennessee's athletic department. While the book mainly focuses on football, there is also a mention or two about men's and women's basketball as well. The bottom line here is it started with the athletic director's office and trickled down through the entire department like a toxic gas, eventually encompassing all sports at the University in some form or fashion.

Mark Nagi is a reporter, sports anchor and photographer who has covered the Volunteers for twenty years and his book is right on point.
I may have met Mark while covering the Vols myself but I'm sure of one thing; he is an accomplished writer and reporter. 

The book begins with the tail end of Phillip Fulmer's tenure as Tennessee's head football coach in 2008. I was still covering Tennessee full-time at WRCB-TV and on more than one occasion I stated on the air that firing Coach Fulmer would be a disaster. My exact words were, " If Fulmer is fired as head coach, the football program will suffer in mediocrity for years." Boy was I correct. This fall marks ten years since Fulmer was let go, thus the " Decade of Dysfunction."

The  most accurate part of Mark's book was his writing about the failed, almost laughable coaching search led by former athletic director John Currie in late 2017. Long-time Tennessee fans, state legislators and many others rose up against the hiring of Ohio State defensive coordinator Greg Schiano as the new head football coach. That uprising did the trick because Tennessee backed out of a Memorandum of Understanding agreement with Schiano. However, that uprising brought down the ire of several members of the national media. Nagi writes, "Across the country Tennessee fans were seen as a bunch of country bumpkins who were mad the Vols' weren't hiring Jon Gruden, so they pitched a hissy-fit."  

That was the same approach others were feeling on the national stage, but they had no idea of the tremendous passion the Big Orange Nation has for their teams. After almost ten years in mediocrity or worse, Tennessee fans had enough. They burned their orange and white Tennessee gear, hundreds protested on campus the day that Currie was supposed to announce the hiring of Greg Schiano and of course thousands and thousands sent emails to university officials saying if Schiano was hired, they were finished with the Volunteers. It worked. It also led to the firing of John Currie in the middle of his coaching search and eventually the demise of Chancellor Dr. Beverly Davenport. It led to the hiring of Volunteer legend Phillip Fulmer as athletic director, who hired former Alabama assistant coach Jeremy Pruitt to be the Vols' 26th head football coach. Fulmer, aka "The Battle Captain" has calmed the storm. He brought Tennessee fans together like no other person on earth could have done.

I recently caught up with Coach Fulmer and told him, when Tennessee brought him back it was one of the happiest days of my life. That was the fan in me speaking. The media person in me was also happy that the Decade of Dysfunction was almost over and we could now concentrate on actually covering the Vols again, rather than the circus that has surrounded the program for ten years or more. Tennessee may have a few more years of mediocrity in football while Pruitt builds his program, but "The Battle Captain" is in charge and that ultimately means stability in the program.

I thoroughly enjoyed reading Mark Nagi's "Decade of Dysfunction." It was well done and accurate and I suggest all Tennessee fans get a copy. It made for a great "beach read" for me. 

-----

Randy Smith can be reached at rsmithsports@epbfi.com


PREP SCHEDULES

FOOTBALL   FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 28 Brentwood Academy at Baylor Boyd-Buchanan at Chattanooga Christian McMinn Co. at Bradley Brainerd at Signal Mountain Howard at Central Cleveland at Maryville Heritage Copper Basin at South Pittsburg Sequoyah at East Hamilton Anderson Co. at East Ridge Grace at Ezell Harding ... (click for more)

Cleveland State Places 3rd At Freed Speed Open

The Cleveland State Community College Cross Country teams competed at the Freed Speed Open this past weekend in Henderson, TN. The weather was not kind, as major rain and thunder rolled in  on Friday . "We were not sure if they would be able to have the race, but the rain and thunder subsided so we were able to continue with the race." said head coach David Kyle. The men's ... (click for more)

Heavy Rains Flooding Many Roads, Some Businesses

Heavy rains throughout Monday brought water over many Hamilton County roads and into some businesses. The front area of the Mapco in the 8100 block of Standifer Gap Road was a small lake. The Sheriff's Office said, "Drivers in the Middle Valley and East Brainerd Road areas are encouraged to avoid driving in low lying areas. All drivers should exercise caution. "Drivers ... (click for more)

Mountain City Club Considering Sale Of Downtown Club To Developer Defoor

Officials of the Mountain City Club are considering sale of the property at Eighth and Chestnut to a developer. Dan Saieed, club president, said the board was approached by developer Byron Defoor with an offer for the property. He said the club is facing declining membership and extreme  financial issues so is considering the offer. The Defoor group developed the nearby ... (click for more)

Why I'm Voting Republican And So Should You

For much of my life, the commitment to the Democratic Party has puzzled me. I was raised to analyze both sides of issues and to make an intelligent decision based upon that information. The values of self-reliance, hard work, and individual liberty that I grew up with were the same American values that have made this country exceptional. As I have grown older, I have witnessed ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: It’s So Sad For Me

I cannot remember a time in my life when I have been as saddened by such a travesty that has now erupted in the confirmation process that would place Brett Kavanaugh on our Supreme Court. I am sad for every single person who has been touched by this catastrophe, from 85-year-old Dianne Feinstein to Brett’s wife and two young daughters, ages 13 and 10. Not a person, in any way involved, ... (click for more)